Same symptoms. Different causes.
Your client reacts to tomatoes every time but aren't on their report — and understating why goes far beyond a single test result.
Understanding an IgG test result is only half the story — knowing what the test doesn’t cover is just as important. In this episode, Anna Pugh and Dr Nigel Abraham go beyond IgG to explore the full picture of food reactions. From enzyme deficiencies to histamine intolerance and break down how to read and communicate a report simply, practically, and with confidence.
By the end of this episode you'll know:
- The difference between IgG food sensitivity and non-immune reactions including lactose intolerance, histamine intolerance, and pseudo allergies
- Why an IgG test cannot diagnose coeliac disease — and when to refer for separate testing
- How cross-reactions work, including between foods and non-foods such as shellfish and house dust mite
- Why foods appear on a report that your client has never eaten
- When to retest and what to realistically expect from a second report
- Why some foods — dairy, gluten, and egg — will almost always appear on a report regardless of what your client eats
Our Chat IgG podcast takes food sensitivity testing from the lab to your clinic. Hosted by industry leading figures Anna Pugh and Dr Nigel Abraham, we’ll take you on a discovery journey across 10 episodes looking at everything from immunology to the clinical process. A must listen to series for absolutely anyone and everyone that wants to learn and understand IgG food sensitivity testing.
Listen on Spotify
Transcript
Anna: Okay before we launch into Podcast 2 there was something that came up after Podcast 1 which we didn't cover which I'm going to cover with Nigel now. Is we talked about immune responses to foods, but what we didn't talk about was the other non-immune responses that we can have to foods which I know is a big topic. But I'm just going to ask Nigel just to break down some non-immune responses that we commonly feel on a day today experience on a day today level.
Nigel: Yeah, as we discussed the first time you know when we're talking about allergies or types of allergy, we had our IgE classical allergies and then we talked a lot about IgG and food sensitivity, but the truth is that there's a whole variety of potential reactions we can have to our food that are neither of those two things. And what's commonly referred to is intolerance is actually reactions to foods which doesn't involve the immune system. So, this time there's no antibodies of any description, so I think probably the best example is lactose intolerance, most people have heard of that, but what is that exactly?
Well, it's actually an enzyme deficiency. We naturally use a lactose enzyme to break down dairy sugars and some people genetically or even acquired can have insufficient levels of that enzyme. So, what's happening, you ingest dairy products you can't properly break them down, so they ferment and cause all sorts of GI type symptoms. So, very often the symptoms will overlap with food sensitivity. This time it's not about looking for antibodies; this is enzyme deficiency. So, you have to have a completely different test to be able to identify that and there are lactose intolerance tests.
Anna: Okay that's important to differentiate, so basically, you can have lots of different reactions to one food. You can have a lactose intolerance; you can have an IgG response to dairy, can also have an IgE response to dairy.
Nigel: From the lab science perspective that's why I say test, test, test.
Anna: Yeah.
Nigel: Because there are different mechanisms which can result in similar symptoms, but they have different tests which show. An IgG test has no value
to look for lactose intolerance and lactose intolerance isn't going to tell you about your food sensitivities.
Anna: That moves slightly neatly on doesn't it to coeliac testing. Now, presumably we're not testing IgE, we're not testing enzyme deficiency, we've got to make quite clear that we're not testing for coeliac disease. This is not a type 1 allergy; coeliac disease is something completely different.
Nigel: That's a very important point because this is an immune disease, but it's not IgE and it's not IgG; coeliac disease is a very specific condition. It's a genetic condition which most people understand is an intolerance to gluten in grains and there's a set of complex immunology going on there. But as you rightly said, there are specific recognised tests to identify coeliac disease, and you can't use a standard IgG test to identify coeliac disease. You may have a gluten sensitivity, but you can't say whether that is coeliac disease without the appropriate test.
Anna: Yeah, that's important because quite a lot of clients who have a strong gluten sensitivity on our test. I will always suggest that they also get coeliac testing separately independent of our results.
Nigel: I think it's prudent, isn't it? You're showing high levels of antibodies to gluten. It's possible if there's a family history for example, then you certainly should seek advice from your GP about should I have a proper coeliac test even if it's just to rule that out?
Anna: Yes, and what about histamine intolerance? Talk a little bit about histamine
because it's been a bit of a buzzword the last couple of years.
Nigel: It does come up a lot in nutritional therapy, doesn't it? Histamine - there are lots of different ways you can have what's called a histamine intolerance. Is defined as when you have more histamine in your body than you're able to get rid of. So, it can be from two different reasons, is you get rid of it via a DAO enzyme so this is an enzyme intolerance again, you might not have enough of that enzyme. Or the activity of that enzyme may be insufficient. That enzyme needs a lot of essential vitamins and minerals to work properly for example, or you've just taken in too much histamine.
Remember, that histamine is present in the food that we eat, so sometimes you're just ingesting a lot of histamine, and you don't really have quite enough of the enzyme to get rid of it. And then you have histamine intolerance which is allergy-like symptoms but again there's no antibodies and that's allergy like reactions.
Anna: That's interesting too because we can also have pharmacological responses to drugs, can't we, that look like allergies or that respond like allergies. That's another non-immune response.
Nigel: Absolutely. There are a number of reactions one that's called fancy names called pseudo allergy and what this is, it actually explains our reactions to drugs
like antibiotics for example. It is a true allergy but how IgE antibodies are not present
so, our normal allergy tests are not helpful for food additives and antibiotics for example and so, you have to have very specialised tests to identify that. So much
so, look when it comes to antibiotics, penicillin allergy most doctors don't test anymore. They go by symptoms you know, the patient has unfortunately had penicillin, you've a fairly clear reaction so that's it. The normal allergy tests are not helpful when it comes to drug reactions and food additives as well.
Anna: Yeah, that's interesting because you know this subject of today's podcast is
interpreting the results and looking at our results. And you know, we would always say that independent of our test results if you know a food is causing a problem, you should avoid it independent of our result. And a lot of people say well, I tested, whenever I eat tomatoes, I get a strong response why a tomato is not on my report?
And I will say, well that's because it's not stimulating an IgG response, but you can have many different responses to that tomato for different reasons.
Nigel: Yeah.
Anna: So, irrespective of our results if you have a problem with a food or a substance it should be avoided.
Nigel: I think we can't emphasise that enough you know. If you have an IgG test, that does not mean you don't have an allergy. In fact, you know it doesn't test for IgE allergies at all. So, use example of tomatoes, maybe completely normal levels of IgG, but you might be allergic to because that's a completely separate test. And interesting of course, you picked on a good example and that tomatoes are really good at histamine induces as well. So, maybe you don't have an allergy or a sensitivity but a histamine problem.
So, it's complex you know, our relationship with food and the reactions we can have for the food there are lots of different ones. IgE is a well-defined allergy which only affects probably 5% of people, so actually lots of people think they have an allergy but very few of them when you get the proper lab test actually do. So, then you have to say, well I'm reacting to something and that tends to be IgG, but it could be histamine, it could be lactose and it could be all sorts of other chemical reactions as well.
Anna: Yeah, that's very interesting and just before we move on to the actual report. Can we retest and when should we retest? Because this is something I get asked a lot and people want to retest after the reintroduction phase because they've done their homework, their symptoms are improved and I will say to them not before 9 months. The proof of the pudding as it were, the gold standard is actually to bring those foods back in. What is your opinion about the timing between tests and retesting?
Nigel: Yeah, this is a common issue which we've discussed many times. I think you're right in that it's very important to not retest too early because it cannot be helpful. IgG antibodies have a long half-life and something we haven't mentioned at the moment is these IgG antibodies form what are called immune complexes. These are very inflammatory things, and they take a long time to remove even after you've successfully removed the food.
So, I think 9 months is a reasonable time before you start retesting, otherwise you run the risk of antibody levels, yeah, being the same or in some cases even higher because at the point you had your first test, you were actively stimulating your immune system. The IgG's were still going up, so probably weeks or even months after you had that test they were still going up and then eventually start coming down, so retesting too early often isn't healthy, it can be disillusion to the client. He says, well I've not got any better, but when you say well, have your symptoms improved they say well, I feel so much better. That's the crucial thing.
Diagnostics tests from CNSLab
Ready to add food sensitivity testing to your practice?
Explore our FoodPrint® home-to-lab test kits and find the right option to support your practice.
Anna: Yeah, we're looking for symptom improvements, alleviating symptoms from clients, absolutely. So, leading on to the test report and I did this test many years ago, maybe 40 years ago and I dismissed the results through ignorance but because foods appeared on my test results that I hadn't eaten, so I assumed that the test was faulty or just not a good representation of my diet. Now, I now know all about cross-reactions and how foods are very very similar in protein structure.
And you may be eating a food may come up on your report that you haven't eaten but it's so similar to another food that you are eating that it will show on the report. Now, when I interpret these reports, I get these cross-reactions almost every single report. Can you go into a little bit more detail about cross-reactions and why they show on a report and how similar these foods have to be.
Nigel: Yeah, that's it's a really important point, I think it's one of the most confusing things to people. They look at the report, they have some food listed, I'm not sure I even know what that food is let alone eating it. But we have to reduce it back to immunology I'm afraid, which is we test the whole food in most cases. But from an immunological perspective that's a huge myriad of different what's called antigens,
the things that you make antibodies to.
And the truth is that some of the most reactive antigens components are often common in a whole variety of different foods. So, we give the food a name but from an immunological term it's actually just that particular component that you're generating antibodies to, and these other five foods have that same component. Sometimes it's very obvious, sometimes it's not obvious at all, so this is exactly the same issue with IgE allergy as well. So, there is a lot of literature where you can look up, if you react to one thing what am I possibly likely to react to as well and it's not cast iron, but it does in general people who react to this often react to that.
I think the other problem is we do our testing all over the world, so what you've often find is local names for essentially the same food. So, the person in Thailand doesn't know cod, but perhaps the fish that they're eating is the same family, does that that make sense?
Anna: Yes.
Nigel: So, their initial response is, don't even know what that is, but when you delve into the local delicacies you can see actually you have very similar fish.
Anna: That's very interesting. And talking about fish, there is also the possibility isn't of cross-reactions not just between food groups but also between foods and non-foods. And I'm thinking particularly shellfish and house dust mite. Now, being an eczema sufferer myself and with a strong IgE allergy to house dust mite, I can't eat shellfish, but I think this is cross-reaction. Can you explain which antigen or protein is causing this this issue?
Nigel: That's a common one, but also the one that seems the most weird, doesn't it?
What I would do is encourage you to have a look at a photomicrograph of a house dust mite and you'll suddenly realise the connection cause it's basically a crustacean. But we don't regard it that way and it has the same common antigen to crabs and lobsters and shrimps. So yes, there is this connection which at first sight is, what is that? But when you look at it down the microscope you can see it's kind of like a tiny little crustacean.
Anna: I like that, I like that description as well of giving foods names because an immunologist such as yourself is not really interested in the name of a food. It's just interested in the individual antigens and structures of the food which are causing the response.
Nigel: In IgE testing we're getting more and more specific now and so, they don't even test the food anymore but all those individual components because it's important for desensitisation therapy.
Anna: Yeah.
Nigel: So yes, if we had our 200-food IgG test and we're all called the chemical name for the antigen, I don't think it would mean a lot to the client, that's the problem. But from an immunological perspective, that's sort of what we're doing but we're doing mixtures of antigens.
Anna: And I think in terms of interpreting the test results, I would say to practitioners, they will often say, goodness they potentially may respond to all these foods. And then you got to bring your practitioner back and say, what foods are they actually eating that you can practically remove from the diet. There's no point in saying just because Brazil nuts may potentially cross-react with cashews and almonds, you need to take those out as well.
Nigel: Yeah.
Anna: I think you need to keep it simple when you're interpreting the results for clients, don't you, not make it complicated. What foods are they actually eating that are potentially stimulating this inflammatory response and symptoms that they can practically take out of their diet and not get too complicated.
Nigel: I think that's right with IgG's concerns which is what we're talking about. Because there is no guarantee that these cross-reactions mean you will react to A, B and C. What's better is to actually test A, B and C and have a look at the results.
I said well, actually I don't seem to be stimulating a response to that so I'm probably going to be OK with it.
Anna: That's really interesting. And another thing that comes up on the report is a client has taken foods out for maybe a year because they know they have a problem with dairy or egg white or barley whatever it is, and those foods will still appear on a report. So how come dairy is showing when they've taken every step to remove it from every angle and every part of their lives. Why would it still show potentially to a lower level not highly elevated but still there in the elevated section.
Nigel: Yeah.
Anna: Why is that still there?
Nigel: I think there are all sorts of potential reasons, right? I mean, it is something we see a lot. I think first of all, there are some foods which are highly allergenic, dairy is something I believe that most humans just about tolerate, some people don't. But even those who do, it's a kind of fine-balance. So, the fact that we all tend to have quite high levels of antibodies to dairy reflects that uneasy relationship and it's very allergic.
So first of all, how easy is it to completely utterly avoid dairy from your diet with modern food? I would imagine it's not always that easy, so you may still be consuming some. You have a sort of immune memory, so if you have introduced some dairy which you didn't realise, the system's already primed, so it's gonna trigger an immune response quite quickly, so your antibodies start going up again.
So, hidden foods is a problem, you don't know you're eating. At the cross-reactions we've already talked about it, maybe you're consuming something similar. But I do also believe that certain core foods, the dairies, the grains, possibly even eggs actually seem to be super allergenic and something that tend to have a high level of
even background antibodies too. So, sometimes they will remain on the report, but again, if you introduce that food, is it causing symptoms, no? Then it's not important.
Anna: The proof of the pudding is bringing those foods back in. Do they stimulate symptoms? Thank you, because that's really interesting that allergenic potential of foods is, I will see on almost every test results.
Nigel: Yeah, it's seen very much in the IgE allergy world. Remember, when it comes to the allergens that we're testing it's essentially the same thing.
Anna: Yeah.
Nigel: It's very difficult to identify why one food is particularly allergenic. Now, there are lots of factors, the biochemical structure, the protein content, all of those things.
But there is no doubt there is difference in the reactivity to different foods to your immune system.
Anna: Okay, thank you for that explanation because it's fairly complex and
you know, we want these reports to be practical and interpretable. We want you to be able to go away to your clients and say, this is what we suggest you do based on the test results in front of you, you can practically remove these foods, we can add other foods.
And we'll talk about food alternatives in our next podcast, what to replace them with. But the fact that most reports will have foods on there that the client isn't eating, so it's good for a practitioner to be aware of that. And it's good to know that some foods have a high allergenic potential, so they will often stimulate a response even if they haven't been eaten, they will be somewhere on the report. So, it's really important to understand that, whenever we look at our clients test results.
Nigel: Absolutely.
Anna: So, thank you for summing that up Nigel.